It has happened with me multiple times that I was requested for a Mock Inspection of NBA accreditation by applying institutes, often 12 to 15 days, ahead of their peer team visit. In nearly all cases, I found utter helplessness in going through the process, finding no way to help them since SAR stood already uploaded/submitted. In at least 50% of cases, applying institutes had engaged some so-called consultant to guide them through the SAR.
Interestingly, most of these institutes had held fairly credible perception in the market.
SAR once submitted is like a bullet, fired. It won’t comeback. And you can’t fire another one. Where most people go wrong in NBA SAR documentation is in the OBE process criterion, largely b’cause of their poor understanding of the process and failure to align assessment of past 2 passed out batches. Many HODs feel that establishing vision, mission, PEO, POs, PSOs and COs and their mapping was all an OBE process, meant. In fact, all of this is only 5 to 10% of OBE, at best.
No idea, why these mock seeking institutions can’t wake up to set their sharp priorities, well ahead of preparing the SAR ? Why go through a mock if a quality work was done on ground documented and can easily be demonstrated? It is so frustrating to see such a bankruptcy in setting priorities.
The aim of mock inspection shouldn’t be only to find fault and give a score. Instead it should include mentoring faculty to meet an upcoming challenge of demonstrating at on ground. When at the very first place, documentation of process is fundamentally flawed, and unsupported by evidence, how can a mock inspector be of any benefit?
In the mock, I try my best not to put the home team off and bottle up my frustration within. However, it strikes me many a times and wish they were wiser in their priorities. Plain speaking, there is a zero need for NBA mock inspection if a capable NBA mentor had built a genuine process in the Department. That’s what an international practice works with ABET, AACSB etc. who have able mentor and coach dedicated to the applying HEIs.
I tell such institutions with wrong priorities, “May the universe conspire and you get visited by such a peer team which is as confused”. Interestingly, there is no dearth of such assessors in the system b’cause far over 90% of them won’t have immersed their own programs into the OBE system in their home institutions.
-Prof JR Sharma : Out of personal experience









